I added the external links, and thank you for putting them in the right place! "I will learn" and I think it should read, The Tamarian language "is" the spoken language of the Tamarians, IMO - STMK.... – The preceding unsigned comment was added by Star Trek Man Kent (talk • contribs) at 2005-05-26T06:52:04.
- Articles about non-objects/places are written in past tense. This is discussed Memory Alpha:Ten Forward#Article Tense|here. --Gvsualan 11:44, 26 May 2005 (UTC)
- Additionally, when possible, use the "Show preview" button prior to your final save, so that you may review what you intend to save. This prevents any unnecessary saves, which otherwise consume a lot of unnecessary space. --Gvsualan 11:49, 26 May 2005 (UTC)
The link to "Video of the Tamarian Language" points to a trailer for the "Darmok" episode, and contains no samples of Tamarian language. It ought to be moved to the page dealing with the episode. -- – The preceding unsigned comment was added by 220.127.116.11 (talk). Guest 15:36, 13 Nov 2005 (UTC)
External Language SourcesEdit
Should we add as much information as possible from external sources such as ? What if that site were to disappear? A lot of that information it contains about the Tamarian Language would disappear along with it. As a Star Trek encyclopedia, perhaps we should try to get all available external information into this one location. Thoughts? --Dogbreathcanada 23:12, 21 January 2006 (UTC)
Kiyazi's children, their faces wet Edit
Someone changed the meaning of this one from "death, mourning" to "It's not serious, I will survive". The new edit is written in the wrong POV, but is the new definition correct? --Bp 09:50, 16 October 2006 (UTC)
- It wasn't me who changed it, but I believe the second definition (It's not serious) is the correct one based on the gesture Dathon made as he said it. Am I right? Who knows? We can only guess. – Gotham23 21:01, 16 July 2009 (UTC)
If you've ever seen a kid fall down, and then start wailing to get parental attention even though they're barely scraped... yeah, I'm betting this means something akin to, "it's only a flesh wound." – The preceding unsigned comment was added by 18.104.22.168 (talk) at 2015-12-02T22:11:11.
"Kadir beneath Mo Moteh" possible alternate translation Edit
In the main article, the translation for "Kadir beneath Mo Moteh" is failure to communicate/ misunderstand.
Given the two instances the phrase is spoken,one when the Tamarian first officer says it while laughing, the other Dathon mutters it, it could be interpreted as directed at an individual. Both instances it seems directed at Picard. In the first instance, Captain Dathon immediatly hushes his first officer with a stern "Temarc". When Dathon mutters it, his frustration with Picard's lack of understanding is rather plain.
Given the metaphoric nature of the Tamarian language, it is quite possible that "Kadir beneath Mo Moteh" is a slight or insult roughly calling in to question the ability to grasp concepts. It could therefore be akin to the 20th century American slang expression "Boy, is this guy dense" – The preceding unsigned comment was added by 22.214.171.124 (talk) at 2006-12-12T09:34:04.
Background note Edit
- The problem with a language based on metaphors is that at some point the stories behind the metaphors must be told in order for them to be understood. Picard was able to teach the Tamarian captain stories about Gilgamesh and Inkido, indicating that Tamarians can understand conventional syntax, but simply choose not to use it communicatively for some reason.
This paragraph seems a bit too opinionated. Perhaps it could be reworded? --From Andoria with Love 03:21, 18 August 2007 (UTC)
- You want to take a shot, be my guest. That's what happened in the episode though. A metaphorical language is nice enough as a plot device, but it has a great big gaping flaw, as I pointed out above.Capt Christopher Donovan 10:07, 18 August 2007 (UTC)
Well, the thing with pointing out flaws is that it is essentially nitpicking, which isn't allowed. That's why I was suggesting it be reworded to be less of a POV and more... encyclopedic. ;) --From Andoria with Love 21:28, 18 August 2007 (UTC)
- I'll give it a shot, but no promises. Just by bringing up the contradiction, it is going to sound "nitpicky" (though I disagree that pointing out flaws is such). Give me a few minutes and see what you think...Capt Christopher Donovan 21:52, 18 August 2007 (UTC)
It still seems a bit nitpicky, but it's better. I'll let it slide. Shhhhh... ;) --From Andoria with Love 04:01, 19 August 2007 (UTC)
- I replaced the line (along with another about Tamarian engineering) with the explanations given in a short story from the TNG 20th anniversary anthology. 'I'm a law student, not a linguist', so I don't know if this covers all the practical problems with Tamarian. It is, however, better than fan speculation/nitpicking.– Cleanse 05:30, 11 May 2009 (UTC)
Picard and Dathon at El-Adrel Edit
Someone defined this as "to work toward a common goal." But isn't that the definition of "Darmok and Jalad at Tanagra?" Why would they need to create a new term for it? I'm positive that "Picard and Dathon at El-Adrel" means "successful first contact between alien cultures," or "to establish peaceful relations," and I've changed the article. I left the alternative definition as acknowledgment that I might be wrong, but I'm pretty sure I'm not. What do others think? – Gotham23 21:06, 16 July 2009 (UTC)
- Since it wasn't said specifically, we should be as broad as possible. In my opinion it was better the first way, but I'm not going to go and change it unless others think so.--31dot 23:40, 16 July 2009 (UTC)
Information on inspirations or connections to other SF would be welcome. For example, the Ascians in Gene Wolfe's The Citadel of the Autarch speak in an almost identical sort of language, but that novel precedes the cited episode by about a decade. (For the relevant excerpts from Citadel see http://probaleo.blogspot.com/2009/01/data-for-clai-2009-paper.html ) Is there a connection or is it just independent invention? --126.96.36.199 00:49, May 11, 2011 (UTC)
Children of Tama Edit
Should we add "Children of Tama" to the list of definitions, translated as "Tamarian"? It seems appropriate to me, but I thought I'd bring it up here before I added it. - Mitchz95 04:35, January 15, 2012 (UTC)
- Seems OK to me. --31dot 12:09, January 15, 2012 (UTC)
Watching a replay of this episode on BBC America right now and wondering - is it really possible to have a language based on metaphor in the way the article explains? I'm not disputing that children could learn the meaning from context and experience - more that someone had to have read, understood, and possibly even written down again the story of Darmok in the first place. It obviously didn't spring full born out the head of the culture. Someone somewhere in Tamarian culture had to get why Darmok would be a good metaphor for him to even be USED as a metaphor. 188.8.131.52 06:42, June 15, 2013 (UTC)
"Kalesh, when it rises!" Edit
I just watched the episode again (one of my favorites) and I have another opinion of the translation (big surprise)...
When Riker and the Tamarian first mate were arguing, the Tamarian cut off transmission right after saying "Kalesh, when it rises!"
To me, that imples that he wasn't willing to do anything until the next day (assuming that Kalesh is a star or moon of some sort).
So basically he's saying, in a short, curt tone, probably because he's under orders he obviously dosn't agree with but is following anyway: "Don't talk to me about this until tomorrow!" (assuming that Kalesh rises daily; or some other period of time)
What do you guys think?
I don't think Temarc just means silence. Perhaps it has to do with playing too much Oregon Trail but...
"Temarc" means there is a division between two things. It could be two people, two ideas, etc. "The river Temarc." means nothing that can be done at present. "Temarc, the river Temarc in winter" means patience can overcome division... on the metaphorical idea that if one waits for winter, the river would freeze over and can then be crossed by walking over the ice, thus the objective is achieved.
I think that makes the dialogue between the Tamarian captain and his first officer clearer as well as the dialogue between Picard and the first officer.
The first time the Tamarian captain says/shouts "The river Temarc in winter" and holds up his hand, he is telling/reminding his first officer to stop laughing and be patient for the communication difficulties can be overcome with time. There is a definite pause between "Temarc" and "in winter" as if they are two separate sentences. It would mean something such as "Stop laughing/do nothing First Officer. Have patience."
The second time the Tamarian captain says "Temarc" and raises his finger he is acknowledging that his first officer has a different opinion (which apparently includes leaving). Then a split second later, the captain stands and says "The river Temarc" saying that there is nothing the first officer can do about it.
When Picard speaks to the first officer he says: "Temarc, the river Temarc in winter."
Basically he is saying there was a division (caused by the Enterprise firing on the Tamarians) and asks for patience. I do not think he is demanding the first officer to quiet down but attempting to explain he has gained understanding/the objective was achieved.
184.108.40.206 08:36, August 14, 2014 (UTC)
Temba, his arms wide/open Edit
I don't think these mean the same thing. I understood it to mean "Temba, his arms open"=offering "Temba, his arms wide"=requesting/accepting.
- When picard offers the captains log as a gift, he says "Temba, his arms open"
- When Picard asks for Dathon to keep talking, he says "Temba, his arms wide"
- When Dathon tells picard to take the torch, he insists "Temba, his arms wide" as if to mean Picard should accept the torch as a gift.
220.127.116.11 19:13, January 23, 2015 (UTC)
Where do the stories come from, I wonder? Edit
So how do the Tamarians tell their stories, particularly to children? There has to be some literal level of their language, even if it is only used with and among children. And the officers could have switched to child-language when they realized they weren't getting through. I am watching this episode for the first time and this is bothering me tremendously. Benkarnell (talk) 14:07, August 3, 2015 (UTC)