Memory Alpha

Talk:Iden's Rebellion

Back to page

41,683pages on
this wiki
Add New Page
Add New Page


Needs some more information on why, how and what the end result of the the rebellion was. -- Q 09:46, 20 Mar 2005 (EST)

deletion discussionEdit

  • Hirogen prey hologram -- Information belongs at Hirogen, seems like an attempt to describe a character and the general events surrounding the Hirogen use of holotechnology at the same time. -- Michael Warren | Talk 16:30, 3 Mar 2005 (GMT)
    • Keep, I can see this being useful. Tyrant 16:36, 3 Mar 2005 (GMT)Tyrant
    • I agree. The article needs work, but the topic has merit. Keep. --Josiah Rowe 17:43, 3 Mar 2005 (GMT)
      • Would it not be better suited at Hirogen? The topic is already covered in fairly good detail the History section of that article. At the very least, it needs a rename and a complete rewrite - leaving the current article in place after a keep would not be good. -- Michael Warren | Talk 18:18, 3 Mar 2005 (GMT)
        • I agree that the article needs a rewrite, but what name would be better than the one it has? --Josiah Rowe 18:35, 3 Mar 2005 (GMT)
          • Holographic Revolution, Hirogen holotechnology, Iden's Rebellion... "Hirogen prey hologram" doesn't sound like a particularly descriptive title for the events that took place. -- Michael Warren | Talk 18:41, 3 Mar 2005 (GMT)
          • I was thinking more of the 'species' not the events. There is a lot to be said. They had a quest, religious beliefs, a little war (this is covered at Hirogen), they took two Voyager crewmembers, they interacted with other species both shown and referenced. We could also have a list of species or even characters that fall into this group. Tyrant 18:28, 3 Mar 2005 (GMT)Tyrant
  • Moved to Iden's Rebellion--Captain Mike K. Bartel 07:59, 9 Mar 2005 (GMT)
    • Nice to see our votes taken so seriously. I stand by my reasoning, a prey hologram and a revolution are not the same thing. Tyrant 11:57, 9 Mar 2005 (GMT)Tyrant
      • I was considering the "species" themselves -- a group of intelligent, or semi-intelligent holograms. They were created from Federation technology and Federation programs -- the share common origins with the Doctor, James Moriarty and Vic Fontaine (Federation AI come-to-life) -- shouldn't then their "species" be hologram? An article defining their creed as a whole would definitely put them in the same room as their holographic brethren. VIVEL'REVOLUTION!!! -- Captain Mike K. Bartel 14:49, 9 Mar 2005 (GMT)
  • I change my vote to delete. I agree with the species working well under hologram. And I agree with events being fine under Hirogen. Tyrant 02:07, 12 Mar 2005 (GMT)Tyrant
      • Do understand -- the original deletion request was over the article title -- since there was both a species and events referred to, and the article title poorly described both. The species was already at hologram, and the events were left open -- there are many more rebellions than just Iden's Rebellion possible to be listed at military conflicts -- i don't think that changing your vote matters at this point as the article has moved and the faulty title was deleted -- the new article stays. -- Captain Mike K. Bartel 20:33, 24 Mar 2005 (EST)

vfd consensusEdit

  • Iden's Rebellion - there is already section in the Hirogen article for this as well. Should this be moved and made into a redirect as well? --Gvsualan (now with boots on...) 19:37, 15 Apr 2005 (UTC)
  • Keep. Agree with Captainmike. A significant event such as Iden's rebellion deserves its own page. -- Lincolnian 23:45, 11 May 2005 (UTC)

Also on Fandom

Random Wiki