| Under the Organians' control, Hoshi and Trip discover they are being watched | |
| Series: | ENT |
| Episode: | 4x11 |
| Original Airdate: | 2005-01-21 |
| Production Number: | 087 |
| Year: | 2154 |
| Date: | Unknown |
| Written by: | Judith Reeves-Stevens & Garfield Reeves-Stevens |
| Directed by: | Mike Vejar |
| |
The non-corporeal Organians study the response of the Enterprise crew to the infection of Hoshi Sato and Tucker by a fatal silicon-based virus brought on board during an away mission.
Summary
As Enterprise orbits a nearby planet, it seems that Travis Mayweather and Malcolm Reed are playing chess on board the ship. In reality, however, they are under the control of two noncorporeal aliens. They talk about the game in technical terms and discuss the humans they are observing on Enterprise. When "Travis" asks "Reed" how the humans will react to what they find on the planet's surface, "Reed" answers that, in his experience, at least one member of every species that have come here has died as a result. He also mentions that some species have lost an entire crew.
Act One
In a shuttlepod, Commander Tucker and Ensign Hoshi Sato return to Enterprise from the M class planet, where they were excavating a Klingon garbage site. Trip hails the starship and speaks with Captain Archer. He tells the captain that their search was unsuccessful. All they found was an old power cell, some empty ration packs and a latrine. Suddenly, Trip starts coughing uncontrollably and eventually collapses. Hoshi informs the senior officers of Trip's condition. "Travis" and "Reed" watch as Archer asks her to pilot the shuttlepod into the launch bay and requests that T'Pol notifies Doctor Phlox to be ready.
Archer and Phlox watch Trip and Hoshi from outside the Decontamination chamber. Archer says that the shuttlepod will have to be inspected to check whether any of its environmental systems were the cause of Trip's condition. Phlox tells Hoshi that three landing parties have returned to Enterprise with no ill effects and passes medkits to them through an opening in the bulkhead. He requires samples of their blood which he can then begin to analyse. Hoshi starts to cough and recalls that Trip started coughing shortly before he lost consciousness. Phlox tells his two patients to get him their blood samples as soon as possible and leaves with Archer. As he and the captain walk through a corridor that leads away from Decon, he informs Archer that he's having difficulty searching for the cause of their infection, using standard scans.
In another corridor, "Travis" mentions that he studied "Reed"'s report on how the Klingons dealt with the infection, to which "Reed" answers that they responded typically for a species at their level of development. When "Mayweather" comments that he believes Archer and the Klingon commander acted differently, "Malcolm" disagrees. "Travis" argues that the Klingon commander didn't allow his landing party to beam back on to their ship, although Archer did. In response, "Reed" explains that both courses of action were extremely similar - the areas of the ship that Trip and Hoshi have visited since their return, the launch bay and the Decon chamber, are completely isolated from the rest of the starship. He claims that it doesn't matter if a member of the landing party returns to their vessel and that the aliens learned everything they can from humans. "Travis" remembers that, like the humans, the Cardassians were also concerned for each other. However, "Malcolm"'s response is that the Cardassians eventually killed the infected members of their crew, as did the Klingons. "Travis" seems hopeful that the humans may overcome the virus, but "Reed" answers that he's been observing aliens for eight hundred years and that he hasn't been surprised yet. Their protocol dictates that they should question the infected crew, which "Malcolm" tells "Travis" to do, and says that he will go to sickbay to speak to Phlox.
In Decon, Trip looks over the temporary medication which the doctor has provided, to be used for muscle pain and nausea. There is also a cough suppressant but Hoshi comments that they aren't coughing any more. She thinks that may be because they're slowly recovering. Trip reminds her that Phlox issued the medication, which he feels is an adequate reason to take them. "Travis" arrives and asks what's in the hypospray. Trip explains that Phlox has been unable to make a diagnosis. "Travis" continues to question them. He asks if they've ever faced serious illness before and how their present condition compares with any other illness they may have experienced. Trip gradually gets annoyed by the entity's questions and eventually closes the hatch that allowed "Travis" to observe.
In sickbay, Phlox is analysing Hoshi and Trip's blood samples when "Reed" enters. He claims he has a headache, so the doctor tries to find some relevant medication. "Reed" is interested in the computer displays of Hoshi and Tucker's blood. Phlox returns and scans "Reed", determining that the headache is not serious. "Reed" explains that it could get worse, though, so Phlox administers him with a mild analgesic. "Reed" asks the doctor how he plans to create an effective antidote but when Phlox begins to believe that "Reed" is afraid that the virus is contagious, he shows him the door.
In Decon, Trip asks Hoshi if she has ever seen a movie from the 20th century entitled, "The Andromeda Strain". Unaware of the film's premise, the semi-delirious Hoshi guesses that it's about a Doctor Andromeda who builds a monster which eventually kills him. When Trip tells her that the film actually involves an alien virus, she replies that she finds it hard to differentiate between the plots of the films that Tucker likes, due to their extreme similarities. Trip recalls that he "got into a lot of trouble" at Starfleet Training Command and Hoshi confesses that she was dismissed from Starfleet. She recalls that when she was trying to run a poker game for some of the new recruits and several members of the training staff stationed there, a Company Commander attempted to terminate the game. As a result, Hoshi, an experienced student of aikido, broke the Commander's arm. Tucker wonders how she managed to be assigned to Enterprise following the incident, to which Hoshi replies that Starfleet was desperate for language specialists and that she was reassigned on probation.
Phlox shows Archer a representation of the virus
In sickbay, Phlox tells Archer that Sato and Tucker are suffering from a silicon-based virus. Archer wonders how the virus could have evolved on an M-class planet, where only carbon-based life is known to exist. Phlox theorises that it may have travelled to the planet on the surface of a meteorite, which could explain why only one of the four landing parties sent by Enterprise contracted it. He informs Archer that there is no record of the virus in the Denobulan medical database, so he'll have to work without prior research. He says that the pathogen is reproducing at an incredibly fast rate and that Hoshi and Tucker may only have five hours to live.
Act Two
As Enterprise continues its orbit of the planet, "Travis" and "Reed" discuss their observations of the crew in the mess hall. "Travis" tells "Reed" that Phlox has managed to make a diagnosis and that no-one on board has made the decision to abandon the infected members of the crew. "Malcolm" believes that everyone aboard the ship will die as a result.
Archer arrives outside the Decon chamber and tries to open the observation hatch. Trip thinks that "Travis" has returned but is relieved to find that his visitor is Archer. He tells the captain that Hoshi is asleep and that the medication which Phlox gave them seems to be working. Archer informs him that the doctor has identified the pathogen but has so far been unsuccessful in creating an antidote. When Trip begins to speak pessimistically about the amount of time he has left to live, Archer tells him that his immune system could still reject the virus. Trip recalls that, due to their carbon-based nature, human bodies don't repel silicon, which he learned from Exobiology 101. When Archer advises him not to give up, Trip seems optimistic about exploring new worlds. Deeply saddened by the engineer's ill health, the captain asks him to rest.
As they walk through a corridor, "Travis" and "Reed" agree that they are searching for indications of advanced rational intelligence within the species which they observe. However, "Malcolm" remarks that Captain Archer hasn't shown signs of rational intellect. By allowing Hoshi and Trip to remain on board, he has increased the possibility that their quarantine may fail. However, "Travis" is certain that Archer knows the risk that the virus represents and that perhaps its not as important to him as being committed to his crew. "Reed" thinks that is as probable as the chance that he is unaware of how unfortunate the situation has become. So, in order to learn whether Archer realizes the risk of contamination, "Travis" suggests that he and "Malcolm" transfer to new hosts. He elects the bodies of Phlox and T'Pol to be used, since Archer's decisions are based on their findings. "Reed" responds by reminding "Travis" that the noncorporeal beings have a strict non-interference policy and claims that the more hosts they occupy, the greater the chance of accidentally influencing the crew. On the other hand, "Travis" states that the more crew members they inhabit, the more they will be able to observe.
In Decon, Trip and Hoshi discuss Sato's linguistic capabilities. Trip reveals that he's always been jealous of her ability to learn new languages, while Hoshi claims that she wishes she had Trip's skill to repair warp engines. He tells her that he hasn't always been good at construction and gives a humorous example of how he once enjoyed taking things apart. Once he has finished recounting the story, Hoshi stands up and sees Phlox and T'Pol at the observation window.
Hoshi sees "Phlox" and "T'Pol"
Unknown to Hoshi, they are now occupied by the noncorporeal aliens, although both she and Trip seem surprised at the sight of them. When Tucker asks how their research is progressing, "T'Pol" replies that they are waiting on some new test results and "Phlox" adds that they came to check the condition of their patients. When Trip asks them to return to sickbay and continue their work, "T'Pol" claims that they immediately intend to do exactly that. "Phlox" is more reluctant to leave than "T'Pol" but eventually does so, too. Hoshi realises that "Phlox" and "T'Pol"'s joint visit could be an indication that they're almost finished their work in sickbay, though Trip isn't as optimistic.
While "Phlox" and "T'Pol" wander through a corridor, "Phlox" comments that Hoshi and Trip are very brave in the way they are facing death. "T'Pol" replies that their intelligence is in question, not their courage. When "Phlox" judges that "T'Pol" wants the humans to fail, she answers that it isn't a contest. She explains that it's more a question of whether the humans are sufficiently intelligent for the noncorporeal aliens to initiate first contact with them. "Phlox" suggests that the aliens also consider other qualities in that decision but "T'Pol" clarifies that they have used that characteristic for ten thousand years. She maintains that they aren't responsible for changing the factor which is used as an indicator but "Phlox" asks who is.
On the bridge, Archer and Reed look over sensor data from the planet below. They have detected a crater, which could prove Phlox's theory that the virus travelled to the planet on a meteorite. The captain thinks that the crater could be the source of the pathogen. If so, the Klingons who set up the campsite which Trip and Hoshi explored would also have been infected. Archer orders Reed to contact Starfleet to find out whether the crew of the Klingon vessel which visited this world were able to develop a cure.
In sickbay, the new test results which Phlox is waiting for are ready. "T'Pol" states that the aliens should transfer into new hosts to allow Phlox and T'Pol to continue their work. They agree to reinhabit the bodies of Malcolm Reed and Travis Mayweather, who are on the bridge, and soon leave Phlox and T'Pol. With no indication of the alien's presence, Phlox observes a viewscreen which shows the results of the blood test he performed earlier. He comments that the alterations they made to the blood's immune receptors weren't effective. Indicating an area of the viewscreen, T'Pol mentions that it may show evidence that the virus is sensitive to fatally extreme ionizing radiation. The doctor agrees and, with his encouragement, she begins to prepare new blood samples for testing.
In Decon, Hoshi wakes from a nightmare. She dreamt that she was in Brazil, where, in reality, she taught as a university professor of languages, shortly before her assignment as Enterprise's communications officer. In the nightmare, which seemed very real to her, a shuttle was on its way to take her to the ship. Tucker reminds her that she is aboard Enterprise, which seems to calm the ensign. She tells Trip that she didn't have enough time to say goodbye to her students but the engineer promises that she will see them again.
Archer shows "Travis" and "Reed" the location of the Klingon alloy
On the bridge, Archer informs "Travis" and "Reed" that he's spoken to the members of Starfleet Command, who are working through diplomatic channels to contact the Klingons. However, their communication may be unnecessary, as Archer has found evidence of a Klingon alloy in orbit of the planet. The alloy is used as the Klingons' standard hull plating and comprises the remains of a Klingon shuttlecraft. Archer has realised that the vessel's crew, infected with the silicon-based virus, were killed by their commanding officer. "Reed" remembers that the crew "didn't even plead for mercy" but, when he notices that Archer is watching him, he disguises the recollection as an observation on Klingon honor. When "Travis" asks if learning about what happened to the Klingons helps the crew of Enterprise in any way, Archer replies that it would be pointless to ask the Klingons for the cure, since they now know that the Klingons didn't develop one. He says that he would do anything it took to acquire the antidote if the Klingons had developed it.
In the Decon Chamber, Hoshi is desperately trying to escape. She frantically speaks several different languages, including a diverse range of Terran as well as Klingonese. When Trip tells her that she won't be able to break the security lock-out code, she answers that "math is just another language". An alarm klaxon blares, signalling that there is a quarantine breach in their area - Hoshi has broken the code.
On the bridge, "Malcolm" reports the breach to Archer and looks at "Travis", surprised by Hoshi's actions.
Meanwhile, Ensign Sato walks through a corridor outside the Decon Chamber in an extremely delirious state.
Act Three
Hoshi opens a door at the other end of the corridor and walks through.
On the bridge, "Reed" informs Archer that the ensign is overriding the safety interlocks on D-Deck. The captain orders him to shut down all power on that deck in an attempt to seal every door there.
Hoshi tries to escape
As Hoshi tries to break through another door, sections of the corridor behind her darken. Eventually, the entire deck is plunged into darkness and a red light is automatically activated. Trip appears behind her and tries to persuade her to stop what she's doing. He tells her that the door which she is attempting to open is actually an airlock. If she succeeds, she and Trip will die of exposure to space. She replies in Russian, insisting that she say goodbye to her students before she leaves for Enterprise. When Trip attempts to hold her back from the airlock, Hoshi wrestles against him. She is weakened by the virus, however, and doesn't have enough energy to fight against him for long. Trip misunderstands her when she says, "I need to tell them...while there's still time". He thinks she is speaking about the senior officers when she says "they", and that she believes that she and Trip will die because of the virus. He reminds her of Archer's determination and leads her back to the Decon chamber, where the alarm ceases to sound. As she rests on one of the bunks there, Trip contacts sickbay and tells Archer and Phlox that they have returned to quarantine. The doctor instructs Trip to use a hypospray and inject Hoshi with three units of sonambutril, an extremely high dosage. The captain adds that the sonambutril will ensure that Hoshi remains in the Decon chamber. Complying with the doctor's orders, Trip remarks on Hoshi's ability to escape. Once he has injected Hoshi, Archer tells him to do the same to himself. When he argues with that decision, Phlox explains that the virus is incompatible with carbon-based life and that the Denobulan hasn't found a method to predict its attack. After some debate, Phlox and Captain Archer persuade Trip to comply. After injecting the sonambutril, the engineer collapses on to the other bunk.
In sickbay, Phlox reports that he and T'Pol have managed to isolate a specific frequency of radiation which disrupts the silicon matrix of the virus. However, the dosage of radiation which the potential patient would have to be subjected to would be lethal. Archer thinks that there must be a way to cure the patient without killing them. Phlox agrees and notifies the captain that he is currently working on that. Archer advises him to quicken his research.
On the bridge, "Travis" walks to the tactical station and whispers to "Reed" that they should stop the effects of the virus. "Mayweather" recalls that they came to observe the crew's reaction to the unexpected, not to watch the crew suffer. "Malcolm" doesn't recommend their discussion take place on the bridge, so "Travis" advises that they speak elsewhere.
In the Decon chamber, Hoshi and Trip sit straight up as they are occupied by the two non-corporeal aliens. "Trip" is surprised by how the sensations of his host differ from those of the other crew members. Uncomfortably, the alien comments that he, like "Hoshi", is also experiencing physical pain. He wonders why humans should endure pain, which he regards as a weakness. "Hoshi" claims that the desire to overcome pain will eventually drive humans to evolve beyond the limitations of the physical world. "Trip" hypothesizes that "Hoshi"'s argument might not be applicable to every species which they encounter but "Hoshi" answers that it can at least be applied to their own species.
In sickbay, Phlox is shocked when he sees "Hoshi" and "Trip" standing in the Decon chamber, talking to each other. He doesn't expect their alien influence and is puzzled that they are even awake. For a brief moment, he watches as the aliens discuss the human and Klingon crews which they have observed. Soon, "Hoshi" senses that they, too, are being observed and the aliens leave their hosts' bodies.
"Archer" and "T'Pol" enter sickbay
When Phlox sees "Archer" and "T'Pol" walk through the doors to sickbay, he expects that they are also their usual selves. He hands "T'Pol" a padd which shows the brain wave patterns of "Trip" and "Hoshi", surprised that the patterns aren't human. When he eventually discovers that Archer and T'Pol are occupied by aliens, Phlox asks whether they are responsible for what happened to Trip and Hoshi. "Archer" responds that they are not, and "T'Pol" explains that they are only interested in studying how physical species respond to the unknown. She adds that Phlox could assist the aliens by explaining how he noticed their presence. The doctor tells them that Hoshi and Trip were sedated and, therefore, should not have been able to stand or talk. "Archer" tells Phlox that they were unable to destinguish between sleep and sedation, as it had been so long since they had inhabited physical beings. When Phlox asks the aliens if they could help Hoshi and Trip, "T'Pol" tells him of their non-interference protocol. The doctor argues that they are interfering with him, which contradicts their protocol, but "T'Pol" replies that they are observing humans, not Denobulans. When the alien informs him that they recently occupied his body, Phlox is surprised that he can't remember that happening but "Archer" tells him of the simplicity of memory adjustment. The doctor believes that since the aliens have the ability to alter human and Denobulan memories, they must also be able to help Hoshi and Trip. "T'Pol" refuses to assist the doctor's patients and thanks Phlox for his help. He, however, is appalled at the aliens' actions and isn't surprised that they erase memories.
Later, "Archer" and "T'Pol" walk through a corridor outside sickbay. "Archer" thinks the humans may have developed a cure for the virus, although "T'Pol" informs him that she has watched several other species develop the same treatment - although after their patients had died. She tells him that they didn't initiate first contact procedures with any of those species and that it would be illogical to have done so. Reminding "Archer" that their current hosts are busy members of the crew, she insists that the aliens return to Travis Mayweather and Malcolm Reed.
As Enterprise continues its orbit of the planet, Phlox and T'Pol report to Captain Archer. Phlox says that if the radiation is to be precise enough as to destroy the virus without killing Hoshi or Trip, the bio-scanner in sickbay will have to be used. T'Pol suggests that the quarantined area is expanded in order to accommodate the infected crew members. Determined to help his crew, Archer replies that implementing Phlox and T'Pol's plan won't be a problem.
Some time later, Phlox notices Hoshi's bio-readings deteriorate. Dressed in environmental suits, he and Archer enter the quarantined area of the ship, as "Travis" and "Reed" watch them on a viewscreen. When they arrive at the Decon chamber, the doctor notes that Hoshi is entering oligemic shock and may soon be dead. Phlox and the captain carry her and Trip into sickbay, where Archer calls that Hoshi isn't breathing.
Meanwhile, "Malcolm Reed" repeats what he said at the start of the episode - "someone always dies".
Act Four
In sickbay, Phlox and Archer attempt to revive Hoshi. Just before Phlox removes one of his EV gloves, the captain stops him and asks what he's doing. The doctor replies that he needs a better grip to operate the medical equipment, so Archer removes his own gloves, saying that a doctor is more urgently required on Enterprise than a captain is. They prepare the equipment for a cardiopulmonary resuscitation technique.
Meanwhile, "Reed" comments that their behaviour is highly unusual. In 800 years, no one else that the aliens have observed has attempted to resuscitate their infected crew.
In sickbay, Phlox instructs Archer to inject forty units of trinephedrine into Hoshi's heart. Phlox also tries to revive her using electrostimulus, but to no effect. Hoshi dies on the medical bed. Next, Archer and the doctor try to save Trip.
Outside the quarantine area, "Travis" wonders why so many humans have to die before "Reed" will acknowledge that they are different. "Reed" answers that he will not ignore the aliens' protocol. He says that the incident which they have been directed to observe isn't over, and, now that the first death has occured on the ship, there is a higher chance that the other crew members will become infected. He reminds "Travis" that the aliens are not responsible for the virus and that members of the crew would have become infected even if the aliens had not observed the situation. "Travis" asks what more can be learned from the humans and that perhaps the aliens should start to take responsibility for the effects of the virus.
Archer covers Hoshi's dead body
In sickbay, Archer completely covers Hoshi with a blanket, signifying Hoshi's passing. He then helps Phlox move Trip into sickbay's imaging chamber, where they radiate his body. When they remove him from the chamber, Phlox murmurs that the procedure was unsuccessful. The doctor says that he did all that he could have done for Trip, but Archer - infected by the virus when he removed his EV gloves - could still be cured in the few hours he has left to live. The captain orders Phlox to go to the bridge instead, saying that the doctor could be infected if he remains in sickbay. Once Phlox has left, Archer contacts the bridge. He makes sure that T'Pol knows she is now in command of Enterprise and tells her not to let Admiral Gardner place anyone else in command. He also says that if Trip regains consciousness, he will immediately inform T'Pol and closes the communication channel to the bridge. Placing a hand on Tucker's chest, he watches a monitor as Trip's low bio-signs fall to zero. Like Hoshi, Trip also dies of the alien virus. Archer is startled when the engineer's body is inhabited by one of the non-corporeal aliens, who tells the captain of the respect the alien has for Archer. When the captain becomes confused at Trip's regaining health, the alien tells Archer that the engineer has been inhabited by an Organian, a "nonphysical life-form". The Organian explains why the aliens come here and repeats information regarding their non-interference protocol. He tells Archer that he wanted to warn the captain of the silicon-based virus, but that decision was not his to make. When "Hoshi" sits up and debates with "Trip" on the subject of the Organians' directives, Archer interrupts that he doesn't care about their rules. When he questions them, "Hoshi" responds that the Organians are instructed to leave their hosts' bodies as they found them - they will have to leave their current hosts dead. The captain agrees that the decision of whether to become involved with a species' natural development is a difficult choice but suggests that the aliens could communicate verbally with their subjects, in order to learn more about them. Hoshi argues that talking is a "limited form of communication" for the Organians, who are much more advanced than that. Archer disagrees, replying that the aliens don't seem more highly evolved than humans, due to the fact that they have lost empathy and compassion - characteristics which give life meaning. When "Hoshi" tells the captain that the Organians will soon leave, erasing his memory of their prescence, she informs him that he will die in three hours. However, "Trip" insists that they save the humans and gives Archer's compassion as a reason. When "Hoshi" promises that the aliens will eventually study other humans, Archer advises her that the Organians experience compassion for themselves, in an effort to learn more about what it means to be human.
On the bridge, Phlox and T'Pol are contacted by Archer, who seems surprised that Hoshi and Trip are alive and well. He asks the doctor and T'Pol to come to sickbay.
Later, Phlox reports that he has detected no sign of the virus in Hoshi, Trip or Archer. He thinks their rejuvenation must have been a delayed result of Commander Tucker's radiation treatment, although that wouldn't explain why Archer and Hoshi are well again. T'Pol suggests that the pathogen's behavior is more unpredictable than she and the doctor had assumed, which may account for Hoshi and the captain's health. Smiling, Archer comments that the virus will later be studied by Starfleet Medical and notifies the crew that he plans to leave a warning beacon in orbit of the planet, to warn visitors of the harmful effects of the virus.
In a turbolift, "Travis" is pleased that the Organians will never be able to observe another species encounter the virus and that, after 10,000 years, the aliens' rules will finally be changing. He informs "Reed" that he plans on advising the other Organians to begin preparations for first contact with humans, which "Reed" suspects will occur in five thousand years.
Enterprise leaves the planet
Finally, Enterprise leaves orbit of the planet.
Memorable Quotes
"Somebody always dies."
- - "Reed"
"Sifting through a Klingon garbage dump is not my idea of exploring strange new worlds."
- - Hoshi Sato
"How do you feel, Trip?"
"Like I got gut punched by a Tellarite."
- - Captain Archer, Trip
"Math is just another language."
- - Hoshi Sato
Background Information
Since the galaxy of TOS seems to be swarming with noncorporeal beings, the producers of Enterprise decided to implement such a race in one of their episodes again. Furthermore, like "Daedalus" before it, Observer Effect is a "bottle show", with less action than usual and no guest stars.
Besides Klingons, another race which the Organians have observed is the Cardassians, a species which is first referenced in Enterprise here. Observer Effect also, therefore, is the first time that the Cardassians are mentioned in the Star Trek timeline.
In quantum mechanics, the Observer Effect theory states that the observation of an experiment changes its results.
Links and References
Guest Stars
None
References
aikido; "The Andromeda Strain"; Cardassians; chess; class M; Gardner, Admiral; Exobiology 101; Klingons; Organian; poker; sonambutril; Starfleet Training Command; Tellarite; trinephedrine.
| Previous episode: Daedalus |
Episodes of Star Trek: Enterprise | ENT Season 4 | Next episode: Babel One |
Revision ID missing! • Date missing! • Blurb