Memory Alpha

Changes: Memory Alpha:Featured article reviews

View source

Back to page

(Janice Rand: remove)
(Janice Rand: successfully removed)
Line 3: Line 3:
==Articles nominated for removal==
==Articles nominated for removal==
[[de:Memory Alpha:Exzellenter Artikel Abwahl]]
[[de:Memory Alpha:Exzellenter Artikel Abwahl]]
===[[Janice Rand]]===
Clearly nominated and approved in the Dark Ages of M/A, I don't find this article particularly impressive by today's standards. When it comes to her later career, there is more background information about the inconsistencies in her rank than there is information on where she appeared or what she actually did. "Flashback" really builds a lot on the Rand character, relatively speaking, and that is barely even explored in the article. In fact, the last sentence in her article isn't even about her, it's about the Excelsior, and has nothing to do with her role in the Excelsior's role. Dinner roll, anyone? Also, while I'm not opposed to the inclusion of images from all her appearances, as it currently stands, there really should be some more text to supplement their inclusion. --[[User:Gvsualan|Alan del Beccio]] 08:59, 9 December 2006 (UTC)
:Mmmm, '''Mild support'''. Not much to the second half of the article. Either it's incomplete or needs to be re-written and re-structured so that the emphasis is on the content, not the background. Also, if it's unclear whether the picture of the "Woman in Cafeteria"/Commander is her or not it should be moved to Background or Apocrypha and noted there. [[User:Logan 5|Logan 5]] 00:55, 16 January 2007 (UTC)
Well, all in all, I think we should recognize all appearances of Grace as Rand, just as we do with all are other background characters played by the same performer. Other than that "BUMP" --[[User:Gvsualan|Alan del Beccio]] 22:36, 6 February 2007 (UTC)
::I'd agree with the removal, for the reasons stated above. It isn't really an "outstanding" article by current standards. -- [[User:Cid Highwind|Cid Highwind]] 00:09, 11 February 2007 (UTC)
:::I'm not sure we should recognize her ''Star Trek III'' appearance as Rand ([[Steve Carnahan]], [[Josh Clark]]), but other than that, it should be '''removed''' based on the fact that it doesn't fully cover her "[[Flashback]]" appearance and so on.--[[User:Tim Thomason|Tim Thomason]] 00:14, 11 February 2007 (UTC)

Revision as of 05:06, March 6, 2007


Articles nominated for removal

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki