Portals People Bajorans Borg Ferengi Humans Klingons Romulans Vulcans Starfleet personnel Society & Culture Borg Cardassian Union Dominion Ferengi Alliance Federation Klingon Empire Romulan Empire Vulcan Science Alpha Quadrant Beta Quadrant Gamma Quadrant Delta Quadrant Technology Spacecraft Starships Spacecraft classes Starship classes Stations All technology The Alternate Reality History People Places Things Spacecraft Starfleet personnel Production Timeline Calendar Performers Studio models Retcons Deleted scenes Unused material Merchandise DVDs Blu-rays Novels Comics Collectibles Series TOS & TAS James T. Kirk Spock Leonard McCoy Montgomery Scott Hikaru Sulu Uhura Pavel Chekov Christine Chapel USS Enterprise TNG Jean-Luc Picard Will Riker Data Geordi La Forge Worf Deanna Troi Beverly Crusher Wesley Crusher Tasha Yar USS Enterprise-D DS9 Benjamin Sisko Kira Nerys Miles O'Brien Odo Jadzia Dax Julian Bashir Quark Jake Sisko Ezri Dax Deep Space 9 VOY Kathryn Janeway Chakotay Tuvok Tom Paris B'Elanna Torres Harry Kim The Doctor Seven of Nine Neelix ENT Jonathan Archer T'Pol "Trip" Tucker Malcolm Reed Phlox Hoshi Sato Travis Mayweather Enterprise NX-01 DIS Michael Burnham Gabriel Lorca Saru Paul Stamets Sylvia Tilly Ash Tyler Philippa Georgiou L'Rell USS Discovery Undeveloped Phase II Federation Final Frontier Episodes Films TOS V'Ger Khan Kruge Whale Probe Sybok Chang USS Enterprise-A I-VI The Motion Picture Wrath of Khan Search for Spock The Voyage Home The Final Frontier The Undiscovered Country TNG Tolian Soran Borg Queen Ru'afo Shinzon USS Enterprise-E VII-X Generations First Contact Insurrection Nemesis Alt James T. Kirk Spock Leonard McCoy Nyota Uhura Montgomery Scott Hikaru Sulu Pavel Chekov George Kirk USS Enterprise USS Enterprise-A XI-XIV Star Trek Into Darkness Beyond XIV Undeveloped Planet of the Titans "Kirk Meets JFK" The First Adventure IMAX The Beginning Memory Alpha Community Introduction Archivists Administrators The Babel Project User projects Ten Forward Reference Desk Chat Involvement Utilities Pages / attention Pages / citation Incomplete articles Stubs Files / attention Files / citation Unused files Watchlist Log entries New Pages Pages for deletion Files for deletion Peer reviews FA nominations FA reviews Policies & Guidelines Manual of Style Copyrights Content Resources Citations Point of view File use policy Spoilers FAQ General Contributions Editing Content Policy Resource Policy Administration Contact Information Privacy Policy Help Logging in Editing pages Edit summary Wiki markup Templates Categories Talk pages

Filter Posts Reset

Categories

Sort By

  • All
  • Following

Spock was 2nd Mutineer

Michael Burnham is labeled "mutineer" but Spock's mutiny ignored. The presiding commodore even said "betraying your captain and ruining his career". Spock went much further, actually taking control of the starship (like his brother Sybok) and violating General Order 7 which carries with it the death penalty! (that's the only case of it)
Spock was convicted by Pike, Kirk, and Commodore Mendez (but then turns out that Mendez was an illusion so I guess it doesn't hold?) Nevertheless, Kirk did convict Spock of mutiny and that was all very much on record without mention of later rescinding.
MB's charges were dropped/pardoned yet she is still labeled as "mutineer" right here on Memory Alpha and throughout fan sites, while Spock walks.
In the movies it seems they are all stealing ships against orders (called mutiny) with ST3 Search for Spock first glaring case. Janeway does the same at the end of Voyager series and gets aiding and abetting by former crew and especially Captain Harry Kim specifically aware of his own mutinous actions.
Spock actually successfully mutinied, kidnapped, earned the death penalty, was formally convicted by two real Starfleet captains all to help an old officer he had a soft spot for.
Burnham didn't do any of that (both she and Spock nerve pinched people) and her motives were anything but personal sentiment and went on to save the universe, her crew's lives multiple times, and end the war (that her "mutiny" was meant to avoid...if only Georgieu woulda stayed down) without committing genocide.
Yet the snarky label follows her and none of the others.
Post image
0 9